Trial by Media

Trial by media contradicts the principle that an accused is innocent until proven guilty by a court of law. Media must cover crime, as it is the responsibility of the media to make the public aware of crimes taking place in the modern world. However, crime must be covered in a way that does not take the form of a media trial, convicting an accused before the court of law delivers its verdict. It is the duty of the court of law to decide, after a fair trial, whether an accused is guilty of an offence or has been falsely implicated.

In modern India, the media acts as the fourth pillar of democracy, alongside the legislature, the executive and the judiciary. It plays an important role in protecting democracy by spreading information and awareness among citizens about the government, its policies and its regulations. It is also a medium through which citizens raise their concerns. The media further acts as an international communicator by carrying world news to Indian citizens and Indian news to the world.

The media plays a vital role in the day-to-day life of the general public. In India, the media derives its rights from Article 19(1)(a) of the Constitution of India. Freedom of the press forms part of the right to freedom of speech and expression. This is a fundamental right guaranteed to the media as well as to the citizens of India, subject to reasonable restrictions. Under this right, the media takes on the responsibility of keeping people aware of events at the national and international level.

In the course of spreading information, the media sometimes conducts a media trial. This affects the lives of the people involved as well as the fairness of the trial. A media trial happens when television, print and social media platforms investigate a case and declare a suspect guilty or innocent before a court of law has reached its final verdict. At such times, news outlets and online platforms act as parallel investigators or judges. They may broadcast sensational details, unverified facts and emotional debates. These can influence public opinion long before due process is complete.

Whether a media trial is healthy or harmful is a debated point. Legal experts and courts often argue that it is harmful. In their view, it violates the presumption of innocence and creates pressure on the judiciary, which may lead to a premature judgement. It can also invade privacy and harm the reputation of an accused who is later found innocent by the court in its final verdict. Proponents and analysts, on the other hand, argue that a media trial has certain benefits. It creates public awareness about crime, legal loopholes and social problems. It may also help expedite investigations by drawing attention to a case. Continuous media coverage can also prompt legal reforms.

Legal experts and courts also point out that a media trial can turn a serious legal case into sensational entertainment aimed at viewership rather than factual reporting. There have been instances where the coverage of an ongoing criminal investigation by news channels and digital platforms has taken this form.

In a landmark judgment, Sahara India Real Estate Corporation Ltd. v. Securities and Exchange Board of India, (2012) 10 SCC 603, the Supreme Court recognised that excessive and prejudicial media publicity can affect the fairness of a trial. The Court held that courts may issue postponement orders to temporarily defer media publications during ongoing judicial proceedings, in order to protect the integrity of the trial.

By Advocate Yatin Mahajan – Senior Panel Counsel for the Union of India and Registrar of Companies High Court of Jammu and Kashmir and Ladakh