Power Tech Global Private Limited (GSTAT Kolkata)
The Scrips That Became Exempt
Export incentives in India have long taken the form of duty credit scrips. An exporter earns a scrip by exporting, and the scrip can be used to pay certain duties or sold to someone who can use it. For many exporters, the sale of scrips is a routine source of cash.
Under GST, the sale of such scrips raised a question about input tax credit. Between 13 October 2017 and 4 July 2022, the sale of duty credit scrips was exempt. A registered person who makes exempt supplies must generally reverse a proportion of its input tax credit attributable to those supplies. Did that rule apply to exempt sales of scrips, even though selling a scrip uses few, if any, taxable inputs?
From 5 July 2022, the answer was clearly no. An amendment to the CGST Rules excluded the value of duty credit scrips from the value of exempt supplies for credit reversal. The question before the Kolkata Bench was about the earlier years.
The question before the Kolkata Bench of the GST Appellate Tribunal in Power Tech Global Private Limited was whether the amendment applied to the earlier period. The Tribunal held that it did not. The amendment was prospective, and credit reversal was required for scrips sold in the intervening period.
But the Tribunal also held that the extended limitation period under section 74 had been improperly invoked, because the taxpayer had disclosed the transactions and the Revenue had failed to establish fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression. The demand was directed to be redetermined under section 73.
The ruling is one of the early decisions of the GST Appellate Tribunal. It answers three questions of wider importance: appeals below a monetary threshold, beneficial amendments and the extended period of limitation.
This article takes up each question in turn, after the facts.
The Facts and the Arguments
The respondent company is a GST registrant that makes electrical equipment.
It also sold MEIS duty credit scrips during financial years 2017-18 to 2019-20. During scrutiny, the department concluded that, under section 17(2) of the CGST Act, 2017 read with Rules 42 and 43 of the CGST Rules, 2017, the company should have reversed proportionate input tax credit attributable to the sale of the scrips, which were exempt supplies.
The sale of the scrips was taxable at 12 per cent from 1 July 2017 to 12 October 2017. An exemption applied from 13 October 2017 under Entry 122A of Notification No. 2/2017-Central Tax (Rate). Later, Notification No. 14/2022-Central Tax dated 5 July 2022 amended Explanation 1 to Rule 43 to exclude the value of duty credit scrips from exempt supplies.
On appeal, the appellate authority set aside the demand, holding that the 2022 amendment was beneficial and retrospective. The Revenue challenged that order before the GST Appellate Tribunal.
The Revenue argued that, for the three years, the scrips were exempt supplies and proportionate credit had to be reversed. The 2022 amendment inserted clause (d) in Explanation 1 to Rule 43 only from 5 July 2022, so it was prospective. The earlier precedents, it said, dealt with different situations.
The taxpayer first raised a preliminary objection. CBIC Circular No. 207/1/2024-GST dated 26 June 2024 set a threshold of Rs. 20 lakh for departmental appeals, and each appeal was below it.
On the merits, the taxpayer said that the amendment only clarified legislative intent and was beneficial, so it should apply retrospectively. MEIS scrips are government incentives for exporters, and selling them does not consume taxable inputs.
The taxpayer also said that it had disclosed all the transactions in its GSTR-3B returns, annual returns and books. The department knew of the MEIS sales, and there was no fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression. Section 74 therefore could not be invoked. In reply, the Revenue said the three appeals together exceeded the threshold, and that the issue recurred and concerned the interpretation of statutory provisions.
These arguments set up three questions for the Tribunal: could the appeal be heard at all, did the 2022 amendment apply to the earlier years, and was section 74 correctly used? The Tribunal answered each in turn, and the answers did not all go the same way.
Maintainability: A Circular Binds Officers, Not the Tribunal
The Tribunal held that the Revenue’s appeal was maintainable. The CBIC circular binds departmental officers, but not the Tribunal.
In any event, the total amount covered by the composite order exceeded Rs. 20 lakh, and the case also involved the interpretation of statutory provisions and recurring issues. Monetary thresholds are an important tool of litigation management. They are meant to keep appeals out of small cases and to focus departmental effort on significant disputes.
Taxpayers often rely on such thresholds when departmental appeals are filed in apparently minor matters. The Tribunal’s reasoning shows the limits of that reliance.
A circular issued by the Board governs the conduct of departmental officers. It does not, of itself, deprive the Tribunal of jurisdiction to hear an appeal that has been filed. Such circulars also commonly contain exceptions for cases involving the interpretation of law or recurring issues.
The threshold may also be assessed by reference to the composite order rather than individual appeals. A taxpayer who wishes to resist a departmental appeal on the ground of the monetary threshold will therefore need to show that the threshold is not met and that no exception applies.
Even then, the argument may not be framed as a bar to the Tribunal’s jurisdiction. The practical lesson is that a circular on monetary limits is a matter between the department and its officers. It may help a taxpayer in a negotiation, or in a request to the department to withdraw an appeal, but it will not by itself end the case before the Tribunal. Taxpayers should therefore prepare to meet a departmental appeal on its merits, even where the amount looks small, and should keep the composite order and the connected appeals in view.
Retrospectivity: Beneficial Does Not Mean Clarificatory
On the merits, the Tribunal held that the amendment of 5 July 2022 was not retrospective.
It observed that duty credit scrips became exempt supplies from 13 October 2017, and that the exclusion of duty credit scrips from exempt turnover under clause (d) of Explanation 1 to Rule 43 was brought in only by Notification No. 14/2022 dated 5 July 2022, with effect from that date.
The Government had the power to give retrospective effect but had consciously not done so. The amendment could therefore not be treated as merely clarificatory or curative. The Tribunal’s approach turns on two things: the text of the notification, which named a prospective date, and the power of the authority to make it retrospective.
Where both are present, an inference that the amendment only clarified the earlier law is hard to sustain. Courts have in some cases given retrospective effect to amendments that remove hardship.
But the beneficial character of an amendment does not, by itself, show that it was meant to apply to the past. The taxpayer’s argument had real force. If the sale of scrips does not consume taxable inputs, credit reversal on such sales has little connection with the purpose of the reversal rules, which is to deny credit attributable to exempt output.
The 2022 amendment may well have recognised that anomaly. But recognising an anomaly for the future is not the same as declaring that the earlier law never required the reversal.
The decision is a reminder that a change in the rules, even a helpful one, operates from its stated date unless the law-maker says otherwise. Exporters who relied on the later amendment for earlier years will need to look for other grounds. Advisers should read the commencement words of each notification closely.
Section 74: Disclosure Defeats Suppression
The taxpayer nonetheless obtained significant relief. The Tribunal held that section 74 had been improperly invoked. The taxpayer had disclosed the MEIS transactions in its GSTR-3B returns, annual returns and records. The Revenue had failed to establish fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression of facts with intent to evade tax.
It relied on two sources:
CBIC Instruction No. 05/2023-GST dated 13 December 2023 and the Supreme Court’s decision in Anand Nishikawa Co. Ltd. The Tribunal directed the proper officer to determine the taxpayer’s liability under section 73, after a hearing and within the prescribed time limits. Section 73 applies to cases other than fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression.
The difference between sections 73 and 74 matters in practice. Section 74 applies where tax has not been paid or credit has been wrongly taken because of fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression of facts to evade tax. It carries a longer limitation period and heavier penalties. Section 73 covers other cases.
Anand Nishikawa was decided under the central excise law. It is often cited for a simple point.
Suppression needs a deliberate withholding of information with intent to evade, and cannot be inferred merely from non-payment. Where the taxpayer has disclosed the facts in its returns and the dispute is only about interpretation, the extended period is ordinarily not available. The Tribunal applied that principle to GST.
The Practical Result
The outcome is a mixed one. The Revenue succeeded on the legal question: credit reversal was required for exempt sales of duty credit scrips between 13 October 2017 and 4 July 2022.
The taxpayer succeeded on the question of the provision under which the liability could be determined. The matter was to be decided under section 73 and not section 74. The MEIS sales were not hidden, since they appeared in the returns and the books.
The disagreement between the parties was only about whether those disclosed sales required credit reversal. Such a disagreement may justify a demand within the normal period, but it does not show an intent to evade. The redetermination under section 73 will take place after a hearing and within the statutory time limits. The effect of limitation on the years in question will depend on that exercise.
The consequences of the direction will depend on the redetermination itself. It may yet reduce the demand.
For exporters who sold duty credit scrips in the exemption period and did not reverse credit, the ruling shows that the 2022 amendment will not protect the earlier years. It also shows that, where the sales were disclosed, the extended period and the heavier consequences of section 74 should not apply.
Both points will matter in pending notices and appeals on the same issue. Exporters should review their positions year by year.
Wider Significance
More broadly, the decision shows how the GST Appellate Tribunal approaches questions that arise often in GST disputes.
Three lessons stand out. Departmental circulars on monetary limits do not bind the Tribunal. Beneficial amendments are not retrospective unless the text or the context says so. And suppression must be established, not assumed, particularly where the taxpayer’s returns disclose the very transactions in dispute. Each lesson reaches beyond the facts of this case.
The first lesson helps the Revenue as much as it limits taxpayers, since it keeps the Tribunal free to hear appeals of principle whatever the amount. The second protects the integrity of the notification process, because a date means what it says.
The third lesson protects taxpayers who deal openly with the department. Disclosure in the returns, with a stated position on the treatment, is a strong answer to an allegation of suppression. A taxpayer who discloses its transactions and takes a position on their treatment has not suppressed anything, even if its position is ultimately rejected.
These points are likely to apply well beyond the sale of scrips. Any dispute about exempt supplies and credit reversal may raise the same questions of limitation and disclosure. Taxpayers with similar notices should compare their facts with those in this case.
The ruling also shows the value of good records. A taxpayer who can show disclosure in each return is in a far stronger position. It should keep copies of the filed returns.
The Link with the 57th GST Council
The ruling complements the recommendations of the 57th GST Council, which call for guidelines on the proper invocation of fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression only on the merits of each case. The Tribunal’s insistence that section 74 cannot be used where transactions have been disclosed is consistent with that direction.
The Council has also recommended a circular on standards for demand notices, adjudication orders and appeal orders, with attention to natural justice and personal hearings. If these standards are applied in practice, fewer disputes may reach the Tribunal on the question of limitation. That would also reduce the burden on exporters.
The Council’s recommendations still await legislative and administrative action, so the Tribunal’s approach will remain an important guide in the meantime. Taxpayers and officers can both rely on its reasoning when they assess how the extended period should be used.
In conclusion
The Kolkata Tribunal’s ruling draws two distinct lines. The first is between a beneficial amendment and a retrospective one. An amendment that removes an anomaly may be welcome, but unless the law-maker has given it retrospective effect, it operates from the date specified.
The second is between a disputed interpretation and an act of suppression. Tax consequences must follow the law as it stood and the facts as they were.